CIM NEWS
« Back to Listings

Goodbye Interactive Whiteboard

2/23/2010
Publisher:School Planning & Management
Author:Glenn Meeks
I am sure a number of readers saw this column's title and groaned.  You thought you were just getting ahead of the curve by working towards installing interactive whiteboards in your  classrooms, and here I am telling you that they are going away.  
 
Don't get me wrong, I am not stating that interactive educational software containing instructional lesson plans from Interwrite Promethean, or SMART Technologies are going away.  In fact, it is those lesson plans that have generated the interest in interactive whiteboards. eBeam Edge Wireless MOBI Epson Projectors

What I am stating, is that it appears the actual surface that is used as the interactive area will be changing.  We will still need to make sure there is a wall space located at the center of the room for interactive display, but you will not need to purchase the actual interactive surface from a manufacturer.  there are two current trends that drive me towards that conclusion. 

What works as an interactive surface for primary grade levels, does not translate well into the middle school and high school environment.  When presented with a choice, the faculty members of four out of five high school projects I have worked on preferred to have wireless slates, rather than the actual interactive whiteboard.  The primary reason was that the teacher did not want to be tethered to the board;  They wanted to be next to David who is trying to sleep in their class.

They also believe it easier to engage the students by handing them the wireless slate, than trying to get them to stand in front of the class (those awkward teenage years). They are still running interactive lesson plans in the classroom using a projector, but the interface device is a wireless handheld device, and the projection surface is a projections screen- pull down or permanent.

That scenario also helps with a secondary issue for middle and high school classrooms. When you place an interactive whiteboard at the manufacturer-recommended height for an adult, the bottom of the image is down around 32 inches above the floor. It is virtually impossible to see the bottom of the image from the back of the classroom- the kids are too tall.

If we no longer need to place the screen where a person can touch or write on it, we can raise it up so the bottom of the viewing image is at 48 inches above the floor, viewable from anywhere in the room.

The other trend is that we do not need actual "interface surface" to run interactive software applications. To start with, take a little time, go to YouTube and search for "interactive whiteboard Wii," and select the one from Johnny Lee (posted a year ago with over 5 million hits). This video demonstrates how you can convert a Nintendo Wii controller into an interactive whiteboard with $65 of parts. The Wii controller is a simple infrared emitter/sensor that he repurposes for an interactive surface.

Johnny now works for Microsoft, and you really need to Google the "Natal Project," which is XBOX upping NINTENDO by eliminating the use of a controller. The Natal Project is a box you place in front of your TV that interprets your body movements and gestures for your game interaction.

Another item you may want to look at is the EIKI (projector manufacturer) Model LC-XIP2000 interactive projector. The interactive sensing device (an infrared emitter/sensor like the Wii) is built into the projector, and you can use any surface you can project the image on as the interactive surface. 

A number of other projector manufacturers are planning similar models. So, for your "wee folk" in primary grade levels, you can have an actual interactive area at the correct height for them without purchasing the expensive interactive surface.

The price cost differential between a wireless slate and projection screen solution for the middle and high school classroom, or an Infrared sensor and projection screen solution in primary grade level classrooms, is at least $1,000 per classroom. You can install the wireless slate solutions in your middle and high school classrooms and a projector with IR sensor in your primary classroom today, and save a lot of money. Hopefully, one of the leading manufacturers will recognize the "dead end" approach of using an actual interactive surface and hook up with one of the university media labs or entertainment companies and adopt an IR emitter/sensor solution themselves. Once that happens, it's the end of the actual interactive whiteboard. 
 
Meeks, Glenn "Goodbye Interactive Whiteboard." School Planning & Management 12 Dec. 2009 December ed. : 13
go
Copyright CIM Technology Solutions - All Rights Reserved
privacy policy  -  site map